Why this page

People describe a breakthrough as a flash. Controlled studies describe work. This page gathers what they measured, as four jobs that recur across science, product design, advertising, music and art, and says where each job sits in our own process.

Feed: start from real material

A review of 43 design experiments asked whether showing designers an example helps them or traps them. With an example in hand, people explored fewer kinds of idea, and the ideas they produced were more novel. The gain was larger when they saw fewer examples, and less common ones (Sio, Kotovsky and Cagan, 2015). One unusual, concrete thing to start from does more than a pile of familiar ones.

Reframe: find the problem first

Getzels and Csikszentmihalyi watched art students set up and draw a still life. Some came with a picture already in mind. Others treated the task as a problem still to be found. Experts judged the second group’s drawings to be better, and those students were the ones who later gained the most recognition as artists (The Creative Vision, 1976).

Import: bring in something from outside

Franke, Poetz and Schreier asked 213 roofers, carpenters and inline skaters for ideas on safety gear, for their own trade and for the other two. Ideas from outside a trade were less ready to use and substantially more novel, and the effect grew as the trades got farther apart (2014). In 166 science challenges open to more than 12,000 scientists, a solver was more likely to win the farther their own field sat from the problem’s (Jeppesen and Lakhani, 2010).

Outside material works in small amounts. Across 17.9 million research papers, the most cited were built mostly on conventional combinations of earlier work, with a small share of unusual ones, and papers with that mix were about twice as likely to be highly cited (Uzzi and colleagues, 2013). Among nearly 27,000 songs on the Billboard Hot 100, the most successful sounded like their peers, with some difference (Askin and Mauskapf, 2017).

Vary and select: make many, keep few

Across creative careers, the number of a person’s hits rises with how much they make, and the share of their work that hits stays about the same (Simonton, 1997). The way to more good work is more work, then choosing.

Order matters. Novices who built several web ads side by side before hearing any feedback made ads that drew more clicks and higher expert ratings than novices who built and revised one at a time, and their designs differed more from each other (Dow and colleagues, 2010). Groups whose members worked alone first and then met produced more ideas and better ones than groups that worked together throughout, and were better at telling which ideas were good (Girotra, Terwiesch and Ulrich, 2010).

Where each job sits in our process

  • Feed. Every framework is written from a person’s public record, and each revision takes in fresh outside material (The open loop).
  • Reframe. A framework carries how a person restates a problem, and the Farthest set breaks something nearly every answer takes for granted.
  • Import. The Far set joins the person’s method to something real from a distant field. The other sets stay closer, because far costs fit.
  • Vary and select. Ideas come fifteen at a time across five sets, each scored blind, and the person chooses.

Scope

These studies cover science, product design, advertising, music and art students.

Sources

  1. Ut Na Sio, Kenneth Kotovsky and Jonathan Cagan, Fixation or inspiration? A meta-analytic review of the role of examples on design processes, Design Studies 39, 2015.
  2. Jacob W. Getzels and Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, The Creative Vision: A Longitudinal Study of Problem Finding in Art, Wiley, 1976.
  3. Nikolaus Franke, Marion K. Poetz and Martin Schreier, Integrating Problem Solvers from Analogous Markets in New Product Ideation, Management Science 60, 2014.
  4. Lars Bo Jeppesen and Karim R. Lakhani, Marginality and Problem-Solving Effectiveness in Broadcast Search, Organization Science 21, 2010.
  5. Brian Uzzi, Satyam Mukherjee, Michael Stringer and Ben Jones, Atypical Combinations and Scientific Impact, Science 342, 2013.
  6. Noah Askin and Michael Mauskapf, What Makes Popular Culture Popular? Product Features and Optimal Differentiation in Music, American Sociological Review 82, 2017.
  7. Dean Keith Simonton, Creative productivity: A predictive and explanatory model of career trajectories and landmarks, Psychological Review 104, 1997.
  8. Steven P. Dow et al., Parallel prototyping leads to better design results, more divergence, and increased self-efficacy, ACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction 17, 2010.
  9. Karan Girotra, Christian Terwiesch and Karl T. Ulrich, Idea Generation and the Quality of the Best Idea, Management Science 56, 2010.